What kind of church is right for me?

I've been going to the Unitarian church, but I don't *feel* it. It satisfies me intellectually, but my soul still feels starved. I admittedly feel attracted to the fundamentalist / evangelical churches around me, with their close-knit groups and their pion and their involvement and their love. I wish I could be a part of it. But I can't do it. I don't believe in the Bible any more than any other religious scripture. So that means I'm not a Christian. I feel so alone...